Pictures of England

Search:

Historic Towns & Picturesque Villages

A picture of RyeBath AbbeyA picture of Bath AbbeyBag End?A picture of Barton Le ClayA picture of Barton Le Clay

Your thoughts on prayer

**Please support PoE by donating today - thank you**
 
Diana Sinclair
Diana Sinclair
Posts: 10119
Joined: 3rd Apr 2008
Location: USA
Posted at 20:34 on 20th August 2008
Sorry folks, that was me, not sure what happened.Undecided
My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Mick Bean
Mick Bean
Posts: 188
Joined: 1st Jun 2007
Location: England
Posted at 20:40 on 20th August 2008

I don’t think believers need to explain to non believers anything. I don’t get non believers knocking on my door telling me I need to rethink my life or life style. I think I understand believers and why they have a faith for reasons I have outlined in my previous input. Never the two will meet, it would be great if folk could open there minds and not feel they have to defend a corner all the time or cleverly reword others input to make there own point more tangible.

 Why is it people how do have a faith feel they have to try and convert me (not everyone of course) what is it I can do if converted that I’m not doing now?

 The bottom line is, we are born, we live and we die. End of story. What makes the difference while we are here is YOU and ME, we are all responsible for our own actions and our lives have nothing to do with any unknown Godlike outside influences. I appreciate that some people think otherwise, that’s always been the case and probably always will.

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
John Ravenscroft
John Ravenscroft
Posts: 321
Joined: 21st Sep 2007
Location: UK
Posted at 20:55 on 20th August 2008
On 20th August 2008 19:49, Barbara Shoemaker wrote:

Thanks, John (I think)!  You're good at this, aren't you?  ;-)  Where I get that "information" from is from the beliefs that I have had for so long, and from what I was taught growing up.  I don't have any specific Bible verses to use to illustrate or prove my statement.  If you're not a believer, then it would probably be wasted effort because you would have to be able to believe the whole story (creation, fall of mankind into sin, God wiping out sinful mankind with a flood, except for a select faithful few, etc.) in order to accept that there would be any purpose to his allowing bad things to happen as part of the process of ultimately bringing the people back to a state of perfection.  My faith is really hard to explain in pieces to a non-believer.  There are a lot of things I believe that I can't prove or explain by tangible, scientific, rational methods but I simply believe them.  I should have said that I believe he allows things .....


Thanks for replying, Barbara.

So would it be fair to say that you believe in God - and the whole Creation Story - simply because that's what you were taught as a child?

If so, what if you'd been born into an Islamic society?

Wouldn't you have been taught that The Koran was the true word of God? And wouldn't you have believed that just as strongly as you now believe in the Bible?

If that's how it is, then it seems to me the religious beliefs people hold are simply a matter of geography.

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Ruth Gregory
Ruth Gregory
Posts: 8072
Joined: 25th Jul 2007
Location: USA
Posted at 21:02 on 20th August 2008
You're all doing a great job here.  A very nice dialogue.  It would take me the rest of the day to respond to everything, and later I just might do it later, because I love to discuss this too, but suffice it to say, that what people of faith believe is due to faith, nothing more, nothing less.  And faith is an act of free will. And yes, it makes no sense, and it can't be proven, apart from effects it has on the life of a believer.  Which goes back to the original concept of the thread - the quote by Joyce Rupp - about how prayer changes us.  And I can say as an eyewitness to my own life that change wrought by prayer in my life is very real indeed.
My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
John Ravenscroft
John Ravenscroft
Posts: 321
Joined: 21st Sep 2007
Location: UK
Posted at 21:12 on 20th August 2008
On 20th August 2008 20:32, unknown wrote:

John, also with due respect (I mean that and am not being facetious); I did not side step your point...

I then proceeded to explain the fact that science has proven that mankind is in fact responsible to a very large degree for so called natural disasters. 
Few doubt that human emissions are causing long-term climate change, which is predicted to increase storm surges, drought and possibly hurricanes. But recent findings indicate that we can also trigger sudden “natural” catastrophes such as mud volcanoes, earthquakes, flooding, and hurricanes to name a few.

In the end John, I think we both know that neither one of us is going to change the other's mind. I think it takes as much faith to NOT believe in God as it does to believe in Him.

I like your inquisitive mind John. It is nice to have someone to "spar" with. LOL!Smile


Diana, are you saying that there were no earthquakes before human beings began meddling with the environment? I'm sure you're not, but that's what it sounds like.

My question remains: why did God make a world in which natural earthquakes etc. wipe out innocent people? Not to mention all the other animals such disasters exterminate.

Barbara has said we can't know the mind of God, so we can't know why such things happen, but when you say:

With little thought to how our environment would be affected we have damaged (possibly irrevocably) our own life support system; and yes, you are right, millions of people have died when they need not have done, all due to the greed of man.

... you seem to be laying the blame for all those lost lives at the feet of Humanity.

It's only in the last 200 years or so that we've had any noticeable effect on our environment. What about all the natural disasters that happened long before that? Can't God be called to account for them?

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Diana Sinclair
Diana Sinclair
Posts: 10119
Joined: 3rd Apr 2008
Location: USA
Posted at 21:42 on 20th August 2008
On 20th August 2008 20:40, Mick Bean wrote:

 The bottom line is, we are born, we live and we die. End of story. What makes the difference while we are here is YOU and ME, we are all responsible for our own actions and our lives



I agree with you up to this point Mick.  I too believe that we have to be responsible for ourselves.
My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Barbara Shoemaker
Barbara Shoemaker
Posts: 1764
Joined: 4th Jan 2008
Location: USA
Posted at 21:43 on 20th August 2008

Thank you, Ruth!  I wondered where you had gone; you were missed. 

 John, I can't speculate on what I would have believed in had I been brought up in a different culture, exposed to a different belief system.  I only know that I have chosen to continue believing in the same God/gospel that I was exposed to all my life.  I have examined it at points in my life and questioned certain things, but at the end of the day came to the conclusion that what I believed to be the Truth is still the Truth.  People from all faiths, or no faith, every day all through their lives or at least at some point in their lives, question what they've been taught, question what they believe, and sometimes change what they believe. I wonder, John, if you had grown up in a Christian home and followed that same faith all your life, might you not now be on the same side of the fence as I? 

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Diana Sinclair
Diana Sinclair
Posts: 10119
Joined: 3rd Apr 2008
Location: USA
Posted at 21:44 on 20th August 2008
On 20th August 2008 21:02, Ruth Gregory wrote:
suffice it to say, that what people of faith believe is due to faith, nothing more, nothing less.  And faith is an act of free will. And yes, it makes no sense, and it can't be proven, apart from effects it has on the life of a believer. 

Agreed! Well said Ruth.Smile
My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Diana Sinclair
Diana Sinclair
Posts: 10119
Joined: 3rd Apr 2008
Location: USA
Posted at 21:51 on 20th August 2008

LOL @ John!  You keep me on my toes! I think we have to agree to disagree on this subject though I would love to continue it if we could sit down over a dinner table loaded with good food and a few bottles of wine. LOL!  Wouldn't that be fun?  My favorite way to spend an evening; sitting around with good friends, good food, good wine and good conversation!

I hate to run folks but I've got a few things that require my attention before I leave work today!

See everyone tomorrow.Smile

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Peter Evans
Peter Evans
Posts: 3863
Joined: 20th Aug 2006
Location: UK
Posted at 22:22 on 20th August 2008

Take care Diana. Catvh you later.

I dont very often get involved in these arguments ie religion. I was thinking of the story of the temptation of Christ. The devil took Jesus up a mountain, and told Jesus that if he followed the Devil,he would give Jesus all that he could see to the far horison. If the earth is Gods domain, how could the Devil give it to Jesus?. Please dont say it is a trick of the Devils. Jesus being Gods son, would know that it belonged to God. So, perhapse this is Hell and God has no say in what happens here.

This is just a thaught from a non believer.

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions