Pictures of England

Search:

Historic Towns & Picturesque Villages

A picture of RyeBath AbbeyA picture of Bath AbbeyBag End?A picture of Barton Le ClayA picture of Barton Le Clay

Your thoughts on prayer

**Please support PoE by donating today - thank you**
 
Alan Marron
Alan Marron
Posts: 726
Joined: 14th Jul 2008
Location: UK
Posted at 15:41 on 27th August 2008
On 26th August 2008 22:23, John Ravenscroft wrote:

No, Diana, I can't break the feelings down. I feel what I feel, and it's impossible to pick that feeling apart and say, 'this came from that hydrogen bond, that came from a frisky carbon atom...'

But I do feel that every thought we have (and every emotion) has its roots in physical brain-activity. Amazingly complex brain-activity - but ultimately just atoms doing what they do.

I don't believe there is any supernatural or spiritual element involved.

I'm not denying that the 'big bang theory' is probably very well founded, even true.  But I cannot believe when I look at the Universe in all its wonderful complexity, that it's nothing more than an accident caused by a super explosion.  It's all much too ordered for that!  The planets, all in their own places, the comets even, hurtling along at super speed, yet keeping to a time table that would be immpossible for any public transport system devised by man.  Everything is so compex, yet so ordered, that in it all I see unmistakably the Hand of God.  I'm just sorry that others cannot see it too, as palainly as I do. 

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Diana Sinclair
Diana Sinclair
Posts: 10119
Joined: 3rd Apr 2008
Location: USA
Posted at 15:44 on 27th August 2008

Well said Alan.  I agree.  The world, the universe, it's all too complex and to ordered to be a mere accident.  Somebody must be holding it all together!

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Alan Marron
Alan Marron
Posts: 726
Joined: 14th Jul 2008
Location: UK
Posted at 16:04 on 27th August 2008

John,  please believe me when I say that I would never try to force my feelings or opinions onto someone else.  It wouldn't be worth it.  Every single person in this whole wonderful world has to find their own way in the tinal analysis.  I've been through a lot, and it would be unfair of me to con you into thinking my faith had never been challenged by my experiences, or that I'd never been found wanting.  But my belief in God is not altered by my acceptance of science.  The two can live together very happily, and without World War 3 breaking out.  Which is wyy I refuse to believe for a single minute that you and I will fal out simply because we have differing points of view.

I willingly respect your position, and hope that in return you will offer me the same simple courtesy.  It's how people of good will, whether Christian or atheist, get on together.

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions


Posts:
Joined: 1st Jan 1970
editPosted at 16:12 on 27th August 2008

Well said Alan, from me too!  The universe, or what we can see of it is, staggering in its complexity and beauty, but there is order in everything. I also see the Hand of God at work.

Mick, speaking only for myself, I have no desire to change your or John's beliefs. I am just defending my own. Like Alan, I am sorry that due credit isn't given to a the Supreme Being for his stupendous handiwork. But that is entirely up to you and I respect that. If anyone is trying to 'convert' around here it's John!!Smile

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Andy Edwards
Andy Edwards
Posts: 1900
Joined: 14th Mar 2008
Location: UK
Posted at 16:34 on 27th August 2008
I'm thinking we'll all find out when the time comes! My recipe for humble pie will be in the appropriate thread.
My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Alan Marron
Alan Marron
Posts: 726
Joined: 14th Jul 2008
Location: UK
Posted at 16:37 on 27th August 2008
On 27th August 2008 16:34, Andy Edwards wrote:
I'm thinking we'll all find out when the time comes! My recipe for humble pie will be in the appropriate thread.
I'm looking forward to seeing your recipe.  Sounds like just what the doctor ordered!
My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Diana Sinclair
Diana Sinclair
Posts: 10119
Joined: 3rd Apr 2008
Location: USA
Posted at 17:08 on 27th August 2008
On 27th August 2008 16:34, Andy Edwards wrote:
I'm thinking we'll all find out when the time comes! My recipe for humble pie will be in the appropriate thread.

LOL @ Andy!  Ditto on what Alan said. LOL!
My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
John Ravenscroft
John Ravenscroft
Posts: 321
Joined: 21st Sep 2007
Location: UK
Posted at 17:55 on 27th August 2008
On 27th August 2008 15:41, Alan Marron wrote:
I'm not denying that the 'big bang theory' is probably very well founded, even true.  But I cannot believe when I look at the Universe in all its wonderful complexity, that it's nothing more than an accident caused by a super explosion.  It's all much too ordered for that!  The planets, all in their own places, the comets even, hurtling along at super speed, yet keeping to a time table that would be immpossible for any public transport system devised by man.  Everything is so compex, yet so ordered, that in it all I see unmistakably the Hand of God.  I'm just sorry that others cannot see it too, as palainly as I do. 


Alan, as I'm sure you know this is one of the classical arguments for the existence of God. It's known as the Argument from Design.

I'd love to discuss it with you (and with Diana and Sue) but I honestly don't want to upset or annoy anyone - so if people would rather let this discussion die a natural death, that's fine by me.

I'd like to clear up an apparent misunderstanding, though.

I'm not trying to 'convert' anyone to atheism. As I've said several times, I enjoy a good, thoughtful, passionate debate - and I've been enjoying this one. I know Ruth (and others) have been enjoying it, too. I hope it continues, because we've hardly scratched the surface here - and I think it's always a good thing to take out our most deeply-held beliefs, oil and polish them, and make sure we still have good reasons for holding them.

Which is why I refuse to believe for a single minute that you and I will fall out simply because we have differing points of view.

I'm sure there's no danger of that, Alan. We're both far too old to start acting like kids in a playground!

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Ruth Gregory
Ruth Gregory
Posts: 8072
Joined: 25th Jul 2007
Location: USA
Posted at 07:02 on 28th August 2008

For a minute I thought Sister Mary Ruth was going to have to show up with her ruler to put this back in order!!  LOL!  But no, I think the kindness and respect that we established early on is holding and you're all to be commended for it.  You are right Mick, about believers becoming defensive and I think you hit the nail on the head, John, when you talked about how emotion enters into it.  It's definitely a hot button topic, and hits people where they live, right in the gut.  And I think the conversations deteriorate, just like in real face-to-face verbal conversations, when you lead with your emotions.  It's important to choose words wisely and meet people where they are.  And as for humble pie, Andy, all of us could use a little slice couldn't we?  LOL.

Thanks for the input guys.  Just like any other of the threads, when people run out of things to say here, the conversation will stop.  But I'm enjoying it.

 What you guys discussed about love and the clinical aspect of it.  I don't dispute any of the research.  I just believe that it originates with God.

 

 

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions
Ruth Gregory
Ruth Gregory
Posts: 8072
Joined: 25th Jul 2007
Location: USA
Posted at 07:03 on 28th August 2008
On 27th August 2008 15:44, Diana Sinclair wrote:

Well said Alan.  I agree.  The world, the universe, it's all too complex and to ordered to be a mere accident.  Somebody must be holding it all together!



I've heard the Holy Spirit referred to as the duct tape of the universe, Diana.  Laughing

 

My favourite: Pictures  |  Towns  |  Attractions